A teacher’s plea: Parents, please allow children to fail


Our guest today is a teacher who has become increasingly frustrated with how quickly parents swoop in to save their fledglings. She has a very clear message: we must allow children to fail, or we are doing them a big disservice.

This generation of parents would like to believe they love their kids more fiercely than any other generation before them. The success of their offspring is proof of that love. Any blunder is considered an indicator of a failure to parent well. 

Sacrifice is just a part of modern parenting. Bending over backwards to ensure that childhood is magical and carefree – and that their offspring receive nothing but positive reinforcement – is part of the package. Successes are collected and celebrated in some misguided notion that this will result in a generation of healthier, happier adults.

Crippled by success

I have been working with children and their families for many years, and I know the opposite to be true. We are currently raising a generation more fearful, more anxious, more unsure than ever before. The reason? I’d speculate that it’s because they have never really tasted failure. Failure provides benefits that can’t be gained any other way. 

We are destined to make mistakes, and privileged to learn from them.

Along with many other educators and coaches around the world, I want you to know that when you step in and save your child from every misstep, and never allow them to fail, you shortchange them. You think you are protecting them, but you are actually disadvantaging them.

“Mistakes are the essence of learning‘” says Mandie Sheanv, a Lecturer at the School of Education, Edith Cowan University, in her article for The Conversation. “If failure is held as a sign of incompetence and something to be avoided (rather than a normal thing), children will start to avoid the challenges necessary for learning.”

Failure helps kids win

Remember that old Irish adage, “I wish you enough rain to enjoy the sunshine”? Without failure, success is just life. And when success is life, then failure can be fatal. When you deny your kids the chance to rise from the ashes of defeat, you only allow them to see part of what it means to be human.

Please, I beg of you, allow children to fail. In fact, allow them to sometimes fail in a spectacular fashion. They will soon know your love is not conditional on their success.

When success is life, then failure can be fatal.

Don’t excuse or explain your child’s poor behaviour. Accept it. Let them learn from it – it’s a valuable part of growing up. As humans, we are intrinsically flawed. We are destined to make mistakes, and privileged to learn from them.

Read this one too: Parenting teens: ‘I was part of the problem’

No judgement here

We know that your children are not an extension of you, they have agency in the world and make their own decisions. We don’t hold you accountable for their actions. We know that you want what’s best for them, we do too!

When an educator or coach disciplines your child, consider backing us! Please don’t take our criticism personally. Instead, make it an opportunity to tell your children that while they will occasionally do the wrong thing, there is dignity in admitting mistakes and making things right. Praise kids for their honesty and help them to make a plan to do better next time.

Show pride in your children’s courage, in their humility, in their very humanity… and watch them grow into confident, resilient, and caring human beings.

Feature image by Priscilla Du Preez; 2 by Sean McAuliffe

A teacher's plea - we must allow kids to fail

Written by Guest Writer

Mumlyfe guests are an important part of our community. We encourage everyone share their story - we all have something valuable to say. Write to us at [email protected] if you would like to share yours.

We’re very social

More for you

“I need your best right now”: How to ask kids to step up

“I need your best right now”: How to ask kids to step up

These here are troubled times and many of us have some very troubled kids on our hands. It's hard to shield them from the COVID-19 news, and as the kids get older we need to ask ourselves if it's even wise to.  "COVID-19 is contagious ... and so is mood," says...

The kids doing school from home is going to kill me

The kids doing school from home is going to kill me

Day one. Day, f'ing ONE. I am no longer worried about coronavirus coming for my kids. I am coming for them myself. Look, tomorrow I will rally and get a grip and do all the things I know I need to do to making our at-home school thrive. Tomorrow. Today I just want to...

Try Peaceful Parenting to help calm the farm

Try Peaceful Parenting to help calm the farm

There is no such thing as stress-free parenting. Peaceful parenting isn’t a place with no stress, but a place where you take the stress as it comes, in stride, and don’t let it rule you. You let it flow through you, and then smile, and breathe, and give your child a...

Affiliate links

From time to time Mumlyfe uses affiliate links.  It means that Mumlyfe may recieve a small commission at no cost to you when you make a purchse using the link.  YOu can find out more about how it works here.

You may also like


Make this one-pot Mediterranean chicken recipe tonight

Make this one-pot Mediterranean chicken recipe tonight

This one-pot Mediterranean chicken recipe from the new book The Feel-Good Family Food Plan makes a great family meal. Throw in whatever veggies you have in the fridge. The book is jam-packed full of everything you need to feed your family well, from one of Australia's...

Start a coronaproject: 17 ways for kids to grow during lockdown

Start a coronaproject: 17 ways for kids to grow during lockdown

A coronaproject is basically the best way to make the most of a really tough situation. No kid enjoys being stuck at home 24/7 with their family, least of all older kids. It's sheer torture, really. We get that. Newsflash: we're not having the greatest time right now...


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This